Orange conaco couldn’t escape whispers during the group’s New York trip. While fans celebrated the album release, eyes turned to her hush-hush meetup with her half-American dancer ex. Spotted in Times Square, the pair stirred drinks—and gossip—like cinnamon whip in coffee.

Adding fuel to the fire, conaco reportedly joined him at a Long Beach volleyball tournament. The same high school “prince” who once stole her heart might just be back in the game, sunglasses and all.